Psychotherapy works through a real relationship, so if something feels off with your therapist, that's worth taking seriously, not pushing past. You can ask questions, name what went wrong in a session, request a change in how you work together, or decide that a different clinician would fit better. None of those options require you to prove your case first.
Not every discomfort means the same thing
Therapy can feel uncomfortable because the work itself is hard. It can also feel uncomfortable because you do not feel heard, the pace is wrong, the approach does not fit, or the therapist crossed a boundary.
Those are different problems, and they call for different responses.
Try completing one sentence:
I notice that after our sessions, I feel ___ because ___.
You may not know the "because" yet. The first half still gives you something concrete to bring into the room, or to a consultation with someone new.
Fit is not a popularity contest
You do not need a therapist who agrees with everything you say. You do need enough trust to be honest, ask what the treatment is doing, and disagree without being punished for it.
NIMH advises prospective clients to ask about a provider's credentials, specialty, treatment approach, goals, how progress will be assessed, and what happens if improvement is not occurring. It also names rapport and trust as essential parts of the work.
Fit includes both the relationship and the competence behind it. Warmth without relevant skill may not be enough. Skill without a workable relationship may not be enough either.
Try naming the rupture
If it feels safe enough, you can say:
- "I left last session feeling misunderstood."
- "I think we are moving faster than I can use."
- "I do not understand why we keep returning to this topic."
- "I need more structure."
- "When you said that, I shut down."
- "I am wondering whether another approach would fit better."
A therapist does not have to respond perfectly in the moment. Their response should make room for the concern, clarify what happened, and help you decide what comes next. Pay attention to whether that room exists at all.
You can ask for a different plan
Sometimes the relationship is workable but the method needs adjusting. Ask what the current goals are, how the therapist understands the problem, what approach they are using, and how you will both know whether it is helping.
You can also ask for a referral to a clinician with a different specialty, identity, schedule, fee structure, or treatment style. Asking does not obligate you to leave. It just gives you more information before you decide.
You can leave without proving a case
You do not need a courtroom argument to end therapy. If the relationship feels unsafe, boundaries were violated, the clinician dismisses reasonable concerns, or you simply decide the fit is wrong, you can leave.
When possible, a closing conversation can help you understand the experience and plan for continuity of care. It is an option, not a debt.
If medication, risk, or an active crisis is part of your care, coordinate the transition carefully with a qualified professional and your existing emergency plan rather than stopping abruptly on your own.
To talk through whether out-of-network telehealth psychotherapy with Mental Wealth Solutions PLLC might be a better fit, book a consultation.
Is it normal to not like my therapist?
Yes. Some discomfort comes from doing hard work in therapy, and some comes from a real mismatch. Naming which one you are feeling is usually the first useful step, whether or not you decide to say anything out loud yet.
Should I tell my therapist that something isn't working?
If it feels safe enough, telling them can help. A specific statement about what happened in a session and what you need instead gives your therapist something concrete to respond to, and how they respond tells you a lot about whether the relationship can hold honest feedback.
How do I know whether to stay or switch?
Look at the pattern across several sessions rather than one hard hour. If the relationship still feels workable and a change to the method might help, ask for that change. If you feel consistently dismissed, unsafe, or unheard, that is a reason to look elsewhere.
Do I have to explain why I'm leaving?
No. You can end care without presenting a case for it. A short closing conversation can help with continuity if a crisis or medication is involved, but outside of that, it is optional.
Can I ask my current therapist for a referral?
Yes. You can ask for a referral to someone with a different specialty, schedule, fee structure, or approach. You can also look for options directly, including a consultation with Mental Wealth Solutions PLLC about out-of-network telehealth psychotherapy.
This article is for educational and informational purposes only. It does not constitute medical, clinical, legal, or therapeutic advice, and reading it does not create a therapist-client relationship with Matthew Sexton, LCSW or Mental Wealth Solutions PLLC. Although the author is a licensed clinical social worker, the content in this article is not clinical assessment, diagnosis, or treatment.
If you are in immediate emotional crisis, you can reach the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline by calling or texting 988 (US). If you are experiencing domestic violence or are in physical danger, contact the National Domestic Violence Hotline at 1-800-799-7233 or visit thehotline.org. In a life-threatening emergency, call 911.
Let's figure out where you go from here.
A free call — and if I'm not the right fit, I'll say so.
Start with a free 30-minute callTelehealth psychotherapy for adults in New York (and Maine, Delaware, and Florida), out-of-network with superbills provided. Specializing in high-functioning anxiety, burnout, complex trauma, and narcissistic-abuse recovery.
No waitlist · No insurance required · Superbills for out-of-network reimbursement