← All writing

Article

Can Research Explain Harmful Workplace Leadership?

Studies of workplace traits, bullying, and culture show associations, but cannot explain or diagnose a particular leader.

Research on workplace leadership can describe patterns in the groups studied, but it cannot explain why a particular person gained power. In research published in 2026, employees rated their perceptions of leaders and workplace relationships, a review examined traits and workplace bullying, and two studies examined organizational culture and unethical behavior.

These PubMed pages were checked November 11, 2026. They offer ways to understand what researchers measured and where they found associations. They do not establish that a specific leader has a personality trait or disorder, or that a trait caused a specific harmful act. If you are trying to describe a difficult workplace experience, begin with what the person did and how it affected you, without assigning a personality label.

By Matthew Sexton, LCSW, NATC

Key takeaways

  • One study of employees’ ratings measured perceptions of leaders, political skill, workplace relationships, and the employees’ own organizational citizenship behavior. It did not diagnose leaders.
  • A review of workplace bullying studies found associations between the traits studied and bullying perpetration, with substantial variation across studies.
  • In two studies of organizational culture, perceptions of an unethical culture amplified the link between Dark Triad traits and unethical behavior.
  • None of these pages explains why a particular person gained power or proves what caused a particular act.

What did the study of employees’ perceptions measure?

The study measured what participants perceived about their leaders and their workplace relationships. Participants rated their perceptions of leaders’ Dark Triad traits and political skill, the quality of their exchange relationship with their leader, and their own organizational citizenship behavior.

That distinction matters when reading about a leader you know. A participant’s rating is a report of perception. It is not a diagnosis of the leader being rated. The fact sheet for this study identifies what participants measured; it does not provide a finding that would let a reader classify an individual leader.

The study also included the quality of the relationship between employee and leader. That is a different question from asking whether the leader has a particular trait. Keeping those questions separate helps prevent a research term from becoming a label for someone the research did not assess.

What did the review find about traits and workplace bullying?

The review found positive associations between the traits it studied and workplace bullying perpetration. It also reported substantial variation across the studies it reviewed.

An association in a review describes a pattern across the research included. The reported variation means the findings were not identical from study to study. Neither point identifies the reason a particular person behaved as they did. The review does not establish that a trait caused any specific act of bullying.

If a workplace interaction is troubling, the behavior itself can be described without trying to infer a hidden trait. What happened, what was said or done, and what effect it had are separate from a claim about someone’s personality. The research supports care with that distinction; it does not supply a diagnosis for people outside the studies.

What role did organizational culture play in the two studies?

The two studies found that organizational culture affected the relationship between traits and unethical behavior. Specifically, perceptions of an unethical organizational culture amplified the link between Dark Triad traits and unethical behavior in those studies.

This finding adds context to a discussion that might otherwise focus only on an individual. It concerns a relationship observed in the two studies, including how participants perceived organizational culture. It does not show why a particular leader gained power or prove that an organization’s culture caused a particular harmful act.

It also does not turn an employee’s impression of a workplace into a verdict about every person in it. The useful distinction is between what the studies found in the groups they examined and what someone can know about a specific workplace from their own observations. Those are different kinds of information.

Can a research label explain one person’s behavior?

No conclusion about one person’s traits, diagnosis, or motives follows from these pages alone. The employee study relied on participants’ ratings of their perceptions. The bullying review reported associations and variation across studies. The culture studies reported how perceived culture affected a relationship between traits and unethical behavior.

Those findings can inform a question about workplace patterns. They cannot settle a question about an individual you have not assessed through the research. Even when behavior is harmful, describing that behavior does not require a personality label. A clear account can stay with observable actions and their effects.

That boundary is especially relevant when a term from a study sounds like an explanation for everything a leader does. The term may name a variable researchers measured, while the question you face concerns a particular event. These pages do not bridge that gap.

Takeaway

The research describes employees’ perceptions, associations in workplace bullying studies, and the role of perceived organizational culture in two studies. It does not explain why any particular person gained power or establish the cause of a specific harmful act. When discussing a difficult workplace experience, describe observable behavior and its effects without assigning an individual a personality label.

If you are in crisis, call or text 988 (US).

Frequently asked questions

Can research tell me why a particular leader gained power?

No. These pages do not establish why any particular person gained power. They address employees’ ratings, associations across workplace bullying studies, and relationships examined in two studies of organizational culture.

Do these studies show that a specific leader has a personality disorder?

No. The study of employees measured participants’ perceptions of leaders; it did not diagnose individual leaders. The other pages do not establish whether a specific leader has a trait or disorder.

Did the review find a link between traits and workplace bullying?

Yes. The review found positive associations between the traits studied and bullying perpetration, while also reporting substantial variation across studies. It does not show that a trait caused a specific act.

What did the organizational culture studies find?

In two studies, perceptions of an unethical organizational culture amplified the link between Dark Triad traits and unethical behavior. That finding does not establish what caused a particular person’s behavior.

Sources

This article is general information, not therapy or medical advice. Reading it does not create a therapist–client relationship.